A School-Focused Decision Matrix and How to Verify Program Data
ASHA EdFind is the first stop for checking a program's self-reported enrollment, completion, and Praxis pass data. Before you rely on a tour, a brochure, or a Reddit thread, turn the finalists into a simple weighted scorecard.
Set weights before you score
Give each factor a weight that matches your priorities, then score every program from 1 to 5. A school-focused applicant will usually weight clinical placement and cost above research prestige, because those two factors shape daily work and monthly loan payments.
- Clinical placement quality (30%): Are school externships supervised, semester-long, and located in districts you would want to work in?
- Cost and debt (20%): Compare total tuition after aid, not the published sticker price.
- Outcome data (20%): Completion rates, Praxis pass rates, and job placement where the program reports them.
- Faculty fit (15%): Do faculty have school-age, literacy, or AAC backgrounds?
- Format and location (15%): Does the mode of delivery and state placement align with your target license?
If a program does not report a factor, score it lower or mark it as missing rather than guessing.
Run the comparison
Use the same anchor for every school: 1 equals weak or no evidence, 3 equals acceptable, and 5 equals strong and documented. Multiply each score by its weight and add the totals. If Program A scores 4 on placement, 3 on cost, 5 on outcomes, 3 on faculty, and 4 on format, its weighted total is 3.85. If Program B lands at 3.45, the difference shows up in numbers instead of relying on a campus visit alone. Run the same math for two or three finalists, then rank them before making any emotional tiebreakers.
Verify claims at the source
Use ASHA EdFind to confirm CAA accreditation and compare program-reported completion and Praxis outcomes against other programs. Then read the graduate catalog for the clinical sequence, externship requirements, and transfer policies. For anything missing, email the program director with specific questions: "Can you share the most recent three years of Praxis pass rates, how many school-based externship sites you filled, and what share of graduates took school-based roles within one year?"
Treat forums as leads, not evidence
A Reddit post such as the r/slpGradSchool thread headed "School SLP Grad Program" can surface the right questions, but it is one anonymous account. Use it to build your checklist, then cross-check every anecdote against the catalog, EdFind, and a direct response from the program before it enters your scorecard.